Mar 7, 2011

James Arthur Ray Sweat Lodge Trial: Day 5


Jennifer Haley


I've checked the CNN live feed at intervals today and as near as I can tell there's been no courtroom broadcast today. So, it's a good time to back up and look at some elements of last week's proceedings.

In Session finally ran more of the opening statements. Prosecutor Sheila Polk laid out the prosecution's case by underscoring the key elements of case as they are to be revealed in upcoming testimony:

  • Participants were being dragged from the tent as early as the fourth round in right front of Ray in obvious distress, displaying nausea, vomiting, and unconsciousness
  • Lou Caci will testify to delirium that resulted in his passing out and falling into the heated rocks where he was badly burned even as he was trying to make a run for the exit
  • Ray did not stop the ceremony despite the chaos and did not check on people when concerns were raised
  • Liz Neuman: Polk points out something on Laura Tucker's testimony that definitely needs to be emphasized -- that it was after Ray had responded to Tucker that Liz knew what she was doing that she said she was fine (implication: she may have been intimidated into refusing help)
  • Medical testimony will explain that heat induces confusion and an inability to discern when one is at risk
  • There were only a few basic medical supplies on hand, no emergency medical plan, only one person trained in CPR on scene, no portable portable defibrillator
  • James Ray endorsed those who had left, including the injured Caci to come back and complete the sweat lodge
  • Sidney Spencer will testify that the back area of the tent where she sat near Kirby Brown and James Shore was hotter, was pitch black, and that she remembers little before losing consciousness and being carried to the opening by James Shore
  • Several people called out for help for Kirby Brown; that she was passed out and not breathing and that James Ray's response was, "We're closing the door. We'll deal with it when we're done."
  • The fire tender's wife looked in the tent at the end and saw three people unconscious, lying on the ground, and she initiated the rescue attempt by tearing open the tent and dragging purple and blue mottled people out -- she also called 911
  • James Ray came out of the sweat lodge first and had his own needs attended to but did nothing to assist others; other participants and volunteers took care of those who were unconscious or otherwise in distress

Polk's oft repeated term for this event is "heat endurance challenge." That sums it up well. As I've said more than once, this was not a sweat lodge in any conventional or traditional sense. Normal sweat lodges are, by Ray's admission (otherwise known as bragging), nowhere near as hot as his. He turned a ceremonial cleanse, normally about as hot as a sauna, into a competitive test of metal.

For the most part I'm ignoring of the In Session commentary because it's just so insipid. But this repeated statement jumped out at me today. Apparently one woman told police that the sweat lodge was so hot that she burned herself on the floor. Think about that for a moment. Heat rises. If the floor -- which people were directed to move towards when they needed relief -- was so hot it could burn someone, how hot was the air above it?

Luis Li opened for the defense. For whatever reason, I find him to be like a human sleeping pill. The segments of the opening statement they ran today, though, are as animated and interesting as I've seen him.

The defense will refute the idea that it was cultish or that Ray conditioned them into participating or staying. They were adults making choices and they signed a waiver. Interestingly, he repeatedly says "it's not quite true" that they were uninformed about various things beforehand. He doesn't say it's untrue... because he can't. As discussed, there was a real paucity of information that could have guided people to seek medical advice or prepare them for how rigorous this thing was actually going to be.

Li also makes clear that participants were free to leave and that some people opted out of various events and some even left entirely.

It's clear that the defense is going to rely heavily on the possibility that the victims were poisoned. They will present witnesses including medical personnel who suspected poisoning. They will contest that the collected samples were not enough to determine whether or not there was contamination. Li explains that Angel Valley owners and employees destroyed the evidence by chopping up and burning the sweat lodge. He says that the owners of the ranch told their employees, "Don't worry. You're not suspects." After suggesting the culpability and cover-up by Angel Valley, and deflecting blame from Ray, he backs up and explains that, no, no one should be a suspect, because this was an accident.

Li also questions much of the procedure from the state examiners who he says did not research thoroughly the possibility of poisoning, having detected some "volatiles" in the samples but not pursuing it further. He also asserts that the state is going to have to prove that it wasn't a poison. This is another clever bit of jujutsu; calling on the state, not to prove their own case and evidence, but disprove evidence that no one actually has. That's a ballsy move. I'm actually kind of impressed.

The defense will also provide its own medical examiner who has examined all the medical records  and come to a different conclusion than the state's examiners; claiming there weren't elevated temps or dehydration.

Today's highlights also included further testimony from Jennifer Haley that I'm assuming transpired after I went out to dinner with my family on Friday. She was very sparkly. (See above.)

Mostly Haley talked about the training and requirements for Dream Team members. There doesn't seem to have been much in that regard. More than anything, Haley doesn't come off as taking a lot it too seriously. She burst into laughter when asked about signing the waiver, saying she just signed it so she could dream team the event. And, let's face it. We've all signed barely comprehensible legal forms so that we could do what we wanted to do. One of her dream team assignments, though, was getting the paying participants to sign the release forms. Here 's Haley on the release forms:

They're very vague if you read them, really! Some of them... they're... So I'd just get 'em to sign whatever papers they put in front of me. I'm just like "here, sign 'em." Or they'll sign, "is it all filled out? Here, you didn't sign this side. Fill that out." I didn't really...

She did not give participants any further information on the events. She did not ask any health questions or obtain any physical exam information. Having read the very perfunctory forms, myself, that comes as no surprise to me.

Haley was also tasked with shaving heads; something her 28 years as a hair stylist did not prepare her for. (You actually have to go to barbering school for that.) She said "a good two thirds" of participants had their heads shaved on the first day. She became uncomfortable when Ray told her to remove the guard from the clippers. At this point, her testimony was cut off for the day, on In Session, but the Salty Droid explains a bit more as to why she was uncomfortable.

Jennifer Haley is a hair stylist by trade {one imagines you’ll have better luck booking appointments in the afternoon}. Jennifer was one of the official head shavers in Death Ray’s totally not cult like head shaving ritual. But James Ray can’t do weenie head shavings like someone else might do :: so he demanded that Ms. Haley remove the plastic guard and go bare clippers. She told him that was a bad idea :: people could get burned or gouged :: “JUST DO IT!!” :: she reenacted him shouting :: “so I did” :: she said … then she kinda giggled.

Haley was, of course, correct. My husband has been shaving his head for years into a Marine Corps high and tight, and there is something of a learning curve. Without the guard you can get nicks, scrapes, and chafing on your scalp. If there are any bumps or abrasions on your scalp you can open up wounds. So, Haley's concern was justified and as someone used to trying to please customers and make them comfortable, she, no doubt, would have found it counter-intuitive to start brutalizing people with electric clippers.

Another aspect of her testimony, which they only showed a glimpse of, had to do with the lack of sleep at the event. Polk asked what they were working on that would keep them up all night. Haley responded that they had "paid a lot of money," at which point, the defense objected, calling it speculation. The combative Haley responded directly to the defense, "It's not speculation because..." at which point Judge Darrow cut her off. So, courtroom procedure is not Jennifer Haley's long suit... making her a FRIGGING RIOT. I hope someone posts video of her testimony because there's just no doing it justice. I'll just say that she should have her own sitcom. I'd watch it.

In another highlight from last week's testimony In Session played today, Melissa Phillips also addressed the money issue. Polk asked about her "investment" of nearly $10,000 in the week-long seminar. Describing that investments' impact on her participation in the event she said, "Yes, I wanted my money's worth."

There was a lot of talk immediately after the tragic occurrences of October 2009 about how improper it is to charge for ceremony. There was also a lot of insistence that Native peoples don't charge. It's not nearly that simple, as I discussed here. But the question of ceremony is specific and it is not common to charge, except sometimes a small donation. In this case, the ceremony was part of a larger training event which makes it a little murkier, though not murky enough to justify the sum in question. (Remember that that ten grand didn't even cover lodging, which was another couple thousand.) But I was contemplating this earlier today, after stumbling on this quote from a Lakota Elder.

When you do ceremony - you can not have money on your mind... The heart and mind must be connected. When you involve money, it changes the energy of healing. The person wants to get what they paid for; the Spirit Grandfathers will not be there, our way of life is now being exploited! You do more damage then good.

I think this especially true when we're talking about people laying out sums that in many cases they can't even afford. And Ray calls these expenditures, "investments." Yes, that terminology comes from him, even though Melissa Phillips owns it in her testimony like she'd made it up -- "I chose to believe in and think of it in such a term, yes." No, that's what James Arthur called it. That's what it's called in the paperwork. It's what he calls all of his fees, including those for the seminars he never gave and won't return the money for. An investment is something that people expect to see some return on. They tend to get annoyed when they don't. It's called a loss. So "investing" a huge, non-refundable sum of money in a seminar does create an incentive to see things through and could certainly motivate a person to see a thing through to its anticipated pay-off.


I mentioned in my previous entry that I thought Ray had taken his whole "spiritual warrior" idea from Carlos Castaneda whose work I described as "crap." That probably deserves a little explanation. I touched on the Castaneda question a while ago here. I would, again, recommend reading the Salon article on Castaneda. It's the best online source I've found on the subject. I read Sorcerer's Apprentice by Amy Wallace some years ago and found it stomach-turning. Wallace was one of Castaneda's followers/mistresses and she describes the cultish elements of Castaneda's inner circle in chilling detail. Little things like how Castaneda required his mistresses bring him "gifts" -- those gifts being more mistresses.

A commenter on The Salty Droid helpfully pointed out that Ray recommends his students read all of Castaneda's work. This can be found on his reading list here. Notice that he recommends reading the books "in order." When someone specifies something like that, it tells you a little something about how much importance they place on a source. So it's Castaneda as holy writ. [sigh] And, especially, notice that his book Practical Spirituality was previously entitled Stop the World. The concept is straight out of Castaneda's books. So, yes, James Ray is basing a lot of his work on Castaneda which means that a lot of his work is based on a thoroughly debunked fraud who manipulated his followers in a myriad of disturbing ways. Why am I not surprised?




My husband and I have several times discussed the new age fascination with the word warrior. To my husband's way of thinking, the word has been reduced to an absurdity. People love to coopt the aura of power and caché associated with warriorship -- the many phony veterans, for example. My husband has read all the Dan Millman Peaceful Warrior books and says, his mythic gas station attendant can be fairly described as an actual warrior. He does a martial art; from the description, most likely aikido. He turns out to be a military veteran. My husband, who as I mentioned, is a Marine, has no bone to pick with Millman. But the way the peaceful warrior idea has been disseminated throughout the ouvre, through no real fault of Millman's, leaves actual warriorship behind. It's become all about self-improvement, facing inner and outer challenges with courage, and so on. Likewise, Castaneda, is all about warriorship as an inner journey towards self perfection. Becoming "impeccable" is certainly a part of warriorship but it's not what defines a warrior. A warrior is someone who is ready to put his or her life on the line for other people.

All information on the trial comes from news articles with provided links or live courtroom footage on TruTV's "In Session" or CNN's live feed. All quotes and paraphrased statements that are not linked to a source document are my best attempt to transcribe material from live broadcasts.


Comments on this entry are closed, on this blog. If you wish to comment, please find this and all newer blog entries crossposted on Celestial Reflections.

Mar 4, 2011

James Arthur Ray Sweat Lodge Trial: Day 4


Jennifer Haley


Yesterday I raised the question of who, if anyone, was actually a paid employee. Dream Team volunteer Jennifer Haley, who just started her testimony at the end of the day yesterday, was asked who was actually getting paid by JRI. Josh and Megan Fredrickson and Melinda Martin were actual, paid employees, according to Haley. Beyond that, she couldn't think of anyone who wasn't a volunteer. I'm glad to see that the prosecution is pursuing this issue because it's very troubling. In part because of what it says about how much they could be fairly depended upon to support participants in these admittedly dangerous activities. That, obviously, is the key issue in this trial. But, in terms of Ray's character, it raises other concerns. This is a man who was teaching about wealth and prosperity and who has claimed to have been very successful. Why does someone running a successful business and living in Hollywood need to have a staff made up almost entirely of volunteers?

This has been a criticism of mine regarding new age organizations and events for years. If someone is making a profit, people who work for them need to receive compensation. In some cases, I can understand, where profit margins are small to non-existent, and volunteers receive some form of fair compensation other than money. Most volunteers at new age events are able to go to lectures and other activities for free. In some cases, depending on how hard they have to work, and how many of the activities they can participate in that can be fair compensation. But this is often not the case and what I've seen, in that regard, at a number of new age festivals and the like has turned my stomach. There are people running events, making substantial sums, who simply exploit a free labor force that's willing to do it because "it's spiritual." If you're operating in integrity -- or to use James Ray's terms, being "impeccable" -- there has to be a fair rate of exchange. That doesn't necessarily mean money. But if someone at the top is making a lot of money and there are a lot of people busting their humps for free, that is not an equal exchange of energy.

While Ray was bragging about his many homes and $10 million net worth, he had a whole cadre of people working for him for free. How does that fit with all of his wealth and abundance memes? He's not sharing the wealth. He's not feeding the economy by employing people. All of his "harmonic wealth" isn't  trickling down onto too many people.

He's also not practicing his "law of attraction" philosophy very well. Now, I'm no fan of The Secret or of the "law of attraction" idea, but I'm familiar with the the belief system. According to the "law of attraction," when you're earning and you have people working for you for free, you are not going to "magnetize" abundance. If you're being cheap with people, you're putting that cheapness out into the universe and will magnetize poverty. If you're putting the people who work for you into a situation where they're working hard and not being compensated, your own work won't bring the compensation it deserves. If you're operating from fear and cleaving to your income instead of sharing your wealth, you will realize your worst fears and magnetize financial problems. I'm not saying that that's why he's harmonic broke. I think it has more to do with the fact that he ran his business and his events recklessly, people died, and he effectively put himself out of business. But by his own professed beliefs, he law of attracted his current financial straits.

According to Ray, himself, his financial situation is dire. It's already been decided that references to his finances are excluded. I'm not sure why; probably something to do with it being prejudicial. But the fact that he was not paying so many people who worked in very rigorous conditions does not look good. According to Haley's testimony, volunteers didn't even get room and board. They had to shell out two grand to stay at the Angel Valley Ranch. While Ray was charging people almost ten grand a piece for the seminar, he wasn't even willing to house the people who were working for him for free.



“In simple terms, if you are thinking, feeling and acting broke, then you’re never gonna attract prosperity into your life. Conversely, if you’re constantly thinking, feeling, acting healthy and whole then you are going to attract and create that in your life.” ~ James Arthur Ray, ABC interview with Dan Harris (2007)


Haley, though, did not return for questioning today. From what I've been able to make out the dispute over the evidence they wanted to introduce with her testimony -- the Kirby Brown recording -- remains unresolved and was tabled for the time being. So this mornings proceedings kicked off with a different witness.




Laura Tucker


Laura Tucker's testimony focused on many questions of health and preparedness for these events. She was asked a whole list of questions about what preparations were made in case someone in the sweat lodge got sick; what she was to do, was there an emergency plan, did she have any expectation that anyone could get sick... She did not. She was asked if she believed the sweat lodge would be a dangerous event. She replied:

I had no expectation that we were going to be in a situation where anyone would come to harm.

She was asked if she knew there was a nurse on site. She had no idea there was a nurse there.

So, there was a nurse present by happenstance, who Ray was looking for to deal with the mess afterwards, but participants weren't informed she was there and had no idea what to do more generally in the event of illness or injury.

Prosecutor Sheila Polk also asked if Laura Tucker was asked any health questions. She did not recall any such questions. Polk asked if she had gone to a doctor for a physical before attending or if she was asked to do so. She did not and was not. 

I thought Tucker appeared very uncomfortable throughout. She was extremely controlled, but in watching her body language, I picked up a lot of hostility and defensiveness. As her testimony proceeded, it became a little clearer to me why that would be and also why Polk was raising so many questions about health issues and how Ray handled them during her testimony. Tucker was sitting with Liz Neuman during the sweat lodge and directly observed her physical distress. This makes her one of the last, if not the last, person to have verbal communication with Neuman before she died.

The most compelling part of her testimony was when a visibly emotional Tucker testified about Liz Neuman and her escalating concern over her during the sweat lodge. Tucker had become concerned because Neuman had moved to a different spot and bent forward into child's pose, a yoga posture they were instructed to do if they became uncomfortable. But Neuman had moved closer to the heated stones, instead of away from them. Later she moved again and rested against Tucker's and her friend Lori's legs and stayed there.

Tucker: I was concerned about Liz. I thought it was odd that we were having to support her as much as we did... It was getting long. Liz was puzzling me. I became concerned and, um, during one of the breaks I spoke up.

Polk: Do you recall what break it was?

Tucker: I think it was after the sixth round.

Polk: And by break what do you mean?

Tucker: When the door of the sweat lodge was open.

Polk: And before you tell us what you did, what specifically about Liz Neuman concerned you?

Tucker: Well, on some level, I was concerned from the moment she moved forward and closer to the stones. Um. You know, and then when she got up and sat it was [pause],  it wasn't altogether unexpected given the idea of inner and outer row but it did seem strange to me. And it was putting a lot of, um, duress or extra effort on me and I imagine Lori as well.

Polk: Could you hear, was Liz saying anything?

Tucker: No.

Polk: Could you hear her breathing?

Tucker: I could.

. . .

Polk: You talked about being concerned. What did you do with your concern?

Tucker: Well during one of the breaks, or when the lodge was open, I called out.

Polk: Who'd you call out to?

Tucker: Mr. Ray.

Polk: Where was Mr. Ray when you called out to him?

Tucker: As far as I know, and I was lying down this whole time, as far as I know he was over near, right near the entrance.

Polk: Could you see when you called out?

Tucker: Not, not particularly well. There, there was some light coming in from the door.

Polk: The door was open when you called out?

Tucker: Yes.

Polk: Tell the jury what you said when you called out.

Tucker: The first time that I called out I said, I said, "James, I'm concerned about Liz."

Polk: What sort of voice did you use?

Tucker: Um, I, I used my own normal voice.

Polk: Ok.

Tucker: And um.

Polk: Did Mr. Ray answer you?

Tucker: Not initially.

Polk: What did you do?

Tucker: Well, I wasn't sure if I was loud enough. So I, uh, I propped myself up a little bit and then I, I made more of an effort to project.

Polk: Ok, and what did you say?

Tucker: I said, "James, it's Laura. I'm concerned about Liz."

Polk: You just used kind of quiet tone here in court. Is that same tone you used?

Tucker: No, it was more forceful than that but I wasn't screaming or yelling or anything.

Polk: Did Mr. Ray respond the second time you called out?

Tucker: He did.

Polk: And what did he say?

Tucker: He, he said, "Liz has done this before Laura. She knows what she's doing."

Polk: After you called out with your concern about Liz Neuman, did Mr. Ray come over and check on Liz?

Tucker: No.

Polk: Did he ask any of his staff to check on Liz?

Tucker: No.

Polk: Did he ask any of his Dream Team members to check on Liz?

Tucker: No.

Polk: Did he ask you for any further information about Liz and what was concerning you?

Tucker: No.

Polk: Did he move from his position at all when he answered you?

Tucker: Not that I'm aware.

Polk: What did you do after Mr. Ray responded in the way that he did?

Tucker: I uh, decided I would ask Liz. So I reached out my left hand. I could reach her shoulder. I touched her on her left shoulder to get her attention. And I asked her, "Liz, are you okay?"

Polk: Did Liz respond?

Tucker: She did.

Polk: And what did she say?

Tucker: She said yes.

Polk: What sort of voice did Liz use when she said yes.

Tucker: It was, you know, maybe a little labored, but...

Polk: Was it very loud?

Tucker: It was loud enough I heard her.

Polk: You were right beside her?

Tucker: I was behind her.

Polk: Did Liz look at you when she responded?

Tucker: She turned her head to the left.

Polk: And where were you?

Tucker: I was immediately behind her.

Polk: Did you do anything further?

Tucker: I did. 

Polk: What did you do?

Tucker: I asked her another question.

Polk: What was that?

Tucker: I asked her if she needed to get out.

Polk: Did Liz respond?

Tucker: She did.

Polk: And what did she say?

Tucker: She said no.

Polk: Did any time pass between the time you asked that question, did she need to get out, and she answered?

Tucker: Only a moment.

Polk: What sort of voice did Liz use?

Tucker: The same.

Polk: And did she move at all?

Tucker: She didn't shift her position, or, you know, other than the turn of the head to answer me?

. . .

Polk: And then Miss Tucker, after that conversation with Mr. Ray and then the conversation you had with Liz, what did you think?

Tucker: [Long pause] Well, one of the things that I was thinking was that I was ready for this whole thing to be over. And I had Mr. Ray you know saying you know let us know what she's doing. I'm not sure if he could see her or not. And I had Liz responding to me promptly and, in my mind, clearly, so I let things be.

Polk: At the time, were you comfortable with letting things be?

Tucker: [Long pause] I'm gonna say, it's what I did, so yes.

Polk: Did you continue to be aware of Liz after that?

Tucker: Yeah, I mean I, I went back, we're talk... this is very late in the, the lodge towards the end at this point. Lori had, had left. And I was, at that point, my thought was, hey, we got this far, we can do one more and that's done.

Polk: Did Liz shift her position at all from that point forward?

Tucker: No, not, no.

Polk: So any change in her position at all with respect to you and leaning on you from that point forward?

Tucker: No.

Polk: Liz make any more sounds?

Tucker: Not, not that, I mean she was there, she was breathing, at no point did she not, she was breathing...

My hunch is that Tucker is carrying a lot of guilt for not having recognized a problem and not having moved more forcefully in getting Neuman help, and that this accounts for a lot of her defensiveness on the stand.

The defense will, of course, say that Neuman made a choice to push through and that no one was at fault.  She was asked if she needed help or needed to get out and she said no. She was a responsible adult and she made a choice. Both Tucker and Ray took her at her word. Although, Ray didn't even wait to hear from Neuman, telling Tucker that she was experienced and knew what she was doing. But Neuman did answer Tucker and she did not accept help. So, Neuman took responsibility for her own health and Ray respected her choice to continue.

The problem is that both Neuman and Ray were wrong. Neither was qualified, nor clear enough, to make that determination. What does that say about their perspective? Three people who thought they were well enough to continue are dead. Many more suffered from heat exhaustion and some have permanent physical damage. Eighteen people went to the hospital. They all thought they were alright enough to continue. They were wrong. At some point you have to ask how effective "knowing your own body" was in that context.

Ray told them repeatedly that even though they might feel like they would die, they wouldn't. They'd been assured that the physical discomfort they would feel was not life threatening. So for the people in that sweat lodge, the conscious choice was not between life and death. It was between enduring physical discomfort and failing to complete their Journey of Power; between suffering through a trial by ordeal and missing out on enlightenment.

That Polk shoehorned in the questions about what health information was required for participants in conjunction with Tucker's testimony was very clever. Because that underscores the lack of preparedness these people had for the real possibility of a health emergency.

My husband and I were discussing some of this over dinner and he raised some interesting points that I hadn't fully considered. I don't generally participate in physically challenging events, so much of the procedure is off my radar. I would never be inclined to do anything remotely like Ray's Spiritual Warrior Training -- well, not if I knew what it really entailed. The only thing on that waiver that would have given me pause would be the going without food and water in the desert. From that form, the physical demands of the event are not clear, and as I've said, I've done sweat lodge ceremony before; the "weenie-ass" kind. But, beyond that, I find all that Castaneda "spiritual warrior" crap to be, well, crap.

My husband, however, is an actual warrior as opposed to a notional one. He is a Marine Corps officer and a martial artist. So he knows a little something about physical rigor and discipline. He is, needless to say, horrified by the physical and emotional challenges Ray put his "spiritual warriors" through. Firstly, because they are patently unsafe. Secondly, because they had no physical training or examination to prepare for any of it.

In the military, of course, you have to be very physically fit to get in in the first place and your fitness and physical health are routinely tested. So to him the idea of putting people who aren't even required to have a health information on record into any physically stressful situation is madness.

He has also done many trainings beyond the military and has always had to fill out a medical history of some kind. The forms vary in their specificity based on how rigorous they are. The Tracker School which is far less rigorous and more loosely structured than Ray's Spiritual Warrior, still requires a health overview. And for an Outward Bound course he was required to fill out an extremely involved health questionnaire. This page explains the very complex process required just to apply. The Outward Bound program, while quite rigorous, was not as dangerous as the Spiritual Warrior seminar. Any martial arts training or competition he's ever participated in has required him to fill out a health questionnaire.

Hell. My daughter had to have a physical and submit her records before she could go to summer camp at the Y.

No one responsible puts people into physically challenging training without some overview of their physical health. No one.

On the one hand Ray was warning them all that his sweat lodge was the hottest they would ever experience but he gave them no guidance on the symptoms of heat exhaustion; how to recognize it or what to do. This is one of the fundamentals you learn in boot camp and Officer Candidate School. It's basic information and very important for any kind of desert training or, as my husband learned, deployment in Iraq. It's one of the first things you learn in the military. But Ray didn't tell these people what warning signs of heat exhaustion participants should be on the look-out for as they went into heat that might make them feel like their skin was peeling off. He didn't tell them what to do if they started to experience symptoms of heat exhaustion. He told them they would not die and that beyond that, they were on their own.

As my husband is fond of saying, "There is no authority without responsibility and no responsibility without authority."

Under cross Tucker rejected the notion of brainwashing and cults.

During the defense's cross-examination, Tucker said it would be wrong to characterize her and others who participated in the retreat as "cult followers" or "brainwashed" -- noting that many were well-educated and successful.

"It was absolutely a massive distortion," she said of media reports, such as that participants were part of a "cult" and subject to "mind control" by Ray.

She's entitled to her opinion and I can understand not wanting to be characterized as a cult follower. But education and success have nothing to do with susceptibility to cult-like manipulation. It really drives home the point for me, though, that I wish the prosecution was focusing more on how people respond to contextual authority than cults, per se. But we'll see what happens with Rick Ross and what he has to say. Still a hard sell. No one likes to think they're submissive to authority.

All information on the trial comes from news articles with provided links or live courtroom footage on TruTV's "In Session" or CNN's live feed. All quotes and paraphrased statements that are not linked to a source document are my best attempt to transcribe material from live broadcasts.


Comments on this entry are closed, on this blog. If you wish to comment, please find this and all newer blog entries crossposted on Celestial Reflections.

Mar 3, 2011

James Arthur Ray Sweat Lodge Trial: Day 3


Melissa Phillips


A few additional thoughts on yesterday's courtroom footage: I guess I expected more from Ray's legal team. I'm not saying that their overall strategy is poor, but in the opening argument, Li was working for the prosecution.

The Salty Droid has posted graphics of the screen shots Li presented of Ray's words. The defense's argument is that the prosecution has taken excerpts of Ray's speeches out of context and they hope to put these back into context. I had trouble making these statements out on my TV but Salty's graphics make clear that the statements they used here to exonerate him just raise whole other questions.

First quote:

You will assist participants as they enter and leave the sweatlodge. If you are inside the sweatlodge, you must remain alert and ready to help the entire time. If you are outside the sweatlodge, be present and ready to quickly and immediately do what is necessary to assist anyone coming out of the sweatlodge.

Second quote:

Now, that being said when we exit, invariably there's at least one or two people, who are like, 'Oh my God it's over I've got to get the hell out of here.' And they and they try to stampede, and that's very dangerous. You're going to have to keep your **** together.

Leaving aside, for the moment, that it's a little alarming that this crack legal team can't get these tapes transcribed with something approaching proper grammar, these statements aren't helpful. I know they're meant to show that Ray was giving responsible instruction and that the problem was that people didn't follow it. The problem is that, Ray didn't follow it. There are too many accounts from participants that he waved people off when they cried out in distress over their own or other people's physical and emotional duress. As Salty points out, two of his top lieutenants also dropped the ball completely. And I think these two are actual employees; not, like much of his staff, unpaid volunteers. (I could be wrong. I'm not really sure if Ray pays anybody to work for him.) And these statements show that he was well aware of how stressed people were going to be. People stampeding to get out of a sweat lodge is not normal. But, again, Ray prides himself on not running your typical "weenie-ass sweat lodge." Yeah, traditional Native American practices are soooo weak.

So Ray knew full well the situation was potentially dangerous, told everyone to be vigilant, but remained oblivious when people started dropping dead. The prosecution is demonstrating that obliviousness and lack of concern, right out of the gate, with its first witness.

Yesterday, Melissa Phillips started her testimony. Phillips shared that she was one of those who "died" in the Samurai Game and went many hours without food or water before the sweat lodge. She shared that she wanted to do the sweat lodge because it was the culmination of the spiritual warrior training and that she was anticipating some sort of enlightening moment.

Ray, Phillips said, “told us that we would feel like we were going to die, but we wouldn’t.”

“I was not aware it was going to be dangerous,” she said. “I was aware it was going to be a challenge.”

. . .


Ray, she said, was sitting in a chair drinking an electrolyte drink and being hosed down.

Phillips quoted him as saying, “I’m not a nurse. Where’s the nurse?”

So, according to Phillips, Ray was waiting for a nurse to handle the problem; a nurse he did not hire to act in her capacity as a nurse. In fact, he hadn't hired her at all. She was one of his many unpaid volunteers.

It should come as no surprise that Phillips didn't understand the actual risks, having taken Ray at his word that no one would die. She does say that Ray said they should use their best judgment in terms of how their own bodies were handling the heat. So that's some acknowledgment from him that people should make decisions for themselves. But he was also telling them flat out that they would not die. This was someone who they knew had done this before and would know the hazards and know how far he could reasonably push them. Phillips makes clear at more than one point in her testimony that if she had known that life threatening injury was a possibility, she would not have taken the risk.

In addition to the fact that he was telling them flat out that they wouldn't die, in spite of their bodies doing some whacky things, in the context of telling them constantly to "play full on" he was challenging them to continue as a matter of personal best and even of attaining "enlightenment."

In today's testimony, defense attorney Tom Kelly asked Phillips about a woman who expressed concern about her high blood pressure condition and wanted to know whether or not it would be safe for her to stay. Ray's response was that he was "not a doctor" and that she had to know her own body and make her own choices. What Kelly is attempting to establish here goes again to the idea of personal responsibility but this is really a double edged sword. It raises the question of the waivers that people signed. Where physically rigorous activity is involved there should be some sort of disclosure of how rigorous and questions about physical ailments that could be contraindicated. Commonly, guidance or permission from a doctor is required. Abnormally hot sweat lodge, total fast in a desert environment... These are exactly the kinds of things a person with a medical condition would need to know in advance and possibly consult a doctor about.

One of the things that came out in Phillips's testimony yesterday had to do with the paucity of information about the nature of the activities. This is from the "Spiritual Warrior Participant Guide," which can be downloaded from the Salty Droid site here.

Keep in mind that we will be working diligently to make this event memorable. For this reason, it is important that we do not disclose any further information regarding the event schedule or planned activities. However, we will tell you that it is going to be an exciting, unforgettable, and transformational week!

Later today, Polk asked Phillips if she knew from the waiver she'd signed that death was a possibility. She said no. And she said, again, that had she known her life could be in danger she would not have participated. Polk also pressed her for more details about the woman who had high blood pressure and jurors learned that she was also overweight and that at the end of sweat lodge, Phillips observed her laying down and being attended to.

Here is what Phillips, the woman with high blood pressure, and other participants learned from the waiver about the risks.

I am fully aware and understand that I will be given the opportunity by the Company to participate in physical, emotional and other activities during the Event, some of which may take place outdoors and/or require the participants to be isolated from one another and/or include very loud music. These activities may include physical exercise (e.g., hiking, swimming, yoga, team games), Holotropic Breathwork (a psychotherapeutic approach believed to allow access to non-ordinary states of consciousness), a sweat lodge ceremony (a ceremonial sauna involving tight, enclosed spaces and intense temperatures), and/or a Vision Quest (a multi- day, solitary, personal and spiritual quest in the wilderness without food or water) (the “Activities”). I am fully aware that I may suffer physical, emotional, financial or other injury during any of the Activities and there is and can be no assurance or guarantee regarding my health or safety in connection with my participation in the Activities. I understand that (1) there are inherent risks in the Activities; (2) people may have been seriously injured by participating in the Activities; and (3) if I voluntarily choose to participate in the Activities, there is a risk that I may receive injuries requiring medical attention. I fully understand and acknowledge that there is no requirement whatsoever that I participate in the Activities. If I do choose to participate in any of the Activities, I affirm that I have not been nor will I be coerced or persuaded in any way to do so and I assume full responsibility for and risk of any injury sustained in connection with the Activities, whether caused by the negligence of Releasees or otherwise.

I also understand that the Company does not purport to offer any medical, psychological, therapeutic, religious, or other professional advice at the Event and that the information provided at the Event is not a substitute for professional psychological or psychiatric care. I agree that under no circumstances shall Releasees be liable to me based on my use or misuse of and/or reliance on any information provided to me at the Event. And I assume full responsibility for and risk of any injury whether personal, financial or otherwise that I might incur based on such use, misuse and/or reliance thereon.

The only information in the "Spiritual Warrior Participant Guide" regarding the nature and risks of the events is in the waiver. While the waiver seems to exonerate JRI of responsibility, it does not, in my opinion, realistically portray the extent of the risks or give adequate information for people with health conditions by which to determine the extent of the physical stressers. It does not, for instance, disclose that Ray's sweat lodge would be much, much hotter than all those "weenie-ass" sweat lodges Native Americans and others do. This would be particularly confusing for anyone who had participated in a traditional sweat lodge in the past and thought they knew what was meant by "a ceremonial sauna involving tight, enclosed spaces and intense temperatures." Having done sweat lodge ceremony myself, I would say that's a fair description of traditional sweat lodge ceremony. It would not have occurred to me, from that description, that it would be sweat lodge as endurance challenge or intentionally much hotter than what I'd experienced in the past. (It also does not disclose that Ray is not certified to facilitate the Holotropic Breathwork. No shock there.) It does not recommend or require people with preexisting health conditions consult their doctor. In short, the intent seems to be entirely for the purposes of protecting James Arthur Ray; not of informing or protecting the participants. Again, my opinion. It will be interesting to see how well those waivers protect Ray, in the final analysis.

The central argument between the prosecution and the defense in this trial comes down to abuse of authority vs. personal responsibility. The waiver is a prime example of that conflict. Boiled down to the essence, that is what jurors will have to decide: Did Ray, as an authority figure have enough influence over his students to overwhelm their best judgment and risk their lives? Or, were these adults making choices of their own free will every step of the way? As pertains the waiver and Ray's repeated statements about how they would not die, the question that arises is, did participants have enough guidance to make informed choices?

As to the larger question about how much influence Ray had, the prosecution will have to prove that it was a manipulative, cult-like atmosphere. The defense has made it clear that it is arguing that these were adults who were free to leave and responsible for their own choices. It's a compelling argument, unless you understand just how heavily inclined we humans are to submit to authority. As of now, I think the prosecution will have a hard time meeting their burden, in this regard. It is still not a certainty that their cult expert Rick Ross will be able to testify or what the scope of that testimony will be. His credentials are very much at issue. As my husband has asked repeatedly, why isn't Phil Zimbardo on the prosecution's witness list? Zimbardo, who is best known for the Stanford Prison Experiment, was a friend of Stanley Milgram and was very influenced by Milgram's groundbreaking research into obedience to authority. The Milgram Experiment demonstrated in study after study that people will defer to perceived authority figures even if it means going against their own morality and ethics. Subjects from all walks of life administered electrical shocks to people they heard screaming from pain as long as someone who appeared authoritative told them to.

If a person in a position of authority ordered you to deliver a 400-volt electrical shock to another person, would you follow orders? Most people would answer this question with an adamant no, but Yale University psychologist Stanley Milgram conducted a series of obedience experiments during the 1960s that demonstrated surprising results. These experiments offer a powerful and disturbing look into the power of authority and obedience.

. . .

The level of shock that the participant was willing to deliver was used as the measure of obedience. How far do you think that most participants were willing to go? When Milgram posed this question to a group of Yale University students, it was predicted that no more than 3 out of 100 participants would deliver the maximum shock. In reality, 65% of the participants in Milgram’s study delivered the maximum shocks.

We all like to think that if we were told to administer painful electrical shocks to another person, we'd refuse, but the research says otherwise. And if you asked the average person on the street if they'd endure vomit, tremor, and unconsciousness inducing levels of heat, we'd forgo our promised enlightenment and leave. But the research of Milgram, Zimbardo, and others, demonstrates that it's not so simple. [No live humans were harmed during this experiment.]





Here is Melissa Phillips describing how she perceived James Arthur Ray:

He was the leader and we had to follow what he said. He was the person I entrusted myself to in the seminar to learn from. I felt he had a reason behind his request.

Clearly, she was not the only participant who invested that much in Ray's authority and guidance.

On cross, Kelly tried to shake Phillips on her observations about Kirby Brown's state during the sweat lodge. She concedes that Brown was so loud in her encouragement of others that people were telling her to keep quiet. The defense is arguing that she was fine and vigorous at that point. But Phillips had repeatedly called out for help for Brown because it was her perception that she was "not in her right mind." Personally, I think the fact that she was yelling and needed to be shushed tends to indicate that Phillips was correct in her observation. The defense is arguing that Brown said she was "fine" when others called for help for her. This is the kind of situation where someone with some actual medical knowledge would have been helpful to determine whether or not she was lucid enough to know if she needed help. Disorientation is a symptom of heatstroke and the medical examiner ultimately determined that heatstroke caused the death of Kirby Brown.

Tomorrow Darrow is expected to rule on whether or not to allow in a recording of Kirby Brown describing her experience during the Samurai Game and how she was so determined to see through her commitment to remaining dead for hours on end that she held her water and even swallowed her own vomit. Darrow has indicated that he may allow it because it goes to Ray's state of mind and his knowledge of the physical and emotional state of participants.

Also of interest in Melissa Phillips's testimony:

Her description of her own physical state following the sweat lodge: Phillips was one of those who had to seek medical attention. She was shaky, unable to stand, nauseous, disoriented and oblivious to her surroundings. The nausea continued and left her unable to eat. She also describes red marks on her skin and fluctuating body temperature and chills for days afterward.

She was able to read into the record what the "Journey of Power" is. The defense worked very hard to keep that out. But Phillips described it as all of the coursework, culminating in the "Spiritual Warrior" training and the sweat lodge which was supposed to be the pinnacle event. This speaks to the investment, monetary and otherwise, participants had in this seminar as a path to their "enlightenment" and "breakthrough."

All information on the trial comes from news articles with provided links or live courtroom footage on TruTV's "In Session" or CNN's live feed. All quotes and paraphrased statements that are not linked to a source document are my best attempt to transcribe material from live broadcasts.


Comments on this entry are closed, on this blog. If you wish to comment, please find this and all newer blog entries crossposted on Celestial Reflections.

Mar 2, 2011

James Arthur Ray Sweat Lodge Trial: Day 2



Well, if I wanted to write about the Casey Anthony trial, I'd have plenty of fodder. Yes, infanticide makes better television than a killer sweat lodge. That probably goes without saying. Of course it may also be that in day 2 the James Ray trial is bogging down over issues like what is the best and least prejudicial way for the state to mark and display evidence. Pretty dry. I'm just disappointed at how little of yesterday's opening arguments are being shoehorned in during breaks in the Florida trial.

So far, between what I've been able to find in articles and what of the prosecution's opening argument I've been able to see when the Casey Anthony trial has been on breaks, I have grokked that the prosecutors intend to use Ray's own words to hang him. After audio of the 911 calls -- always disturbing -- prosecutor Sheila Polk played long excerpts from Ray's recorded speeches to his "spiritual warriors."

Much of it is repetitive and nonsensical gibberish. But even in these snippets there are some major red flags.

Welcome to spiritual warrior. Time is short. Time is short. If you're not going to die, it is. Some of you went to bed last night. That's okay. Time is short. Tick tok, tick tok, tick tok, tick tok. It's getting shorter. Better clean it up while you can. You don't have a lot of time left. A spiritual warrior. From the time they were born until the time they exited this particular lifetime, they were told and trained and prepared for the ultimate battle. It was their purpose. It's why you're here. So the battle is coming. That's why you're here. You didn't choose it. The choice has already been made. You were born and that's who you are. And between the time of birth to the exit in the final battle, the ultimate battle, you either live an honorable life, you live with impeccability, you devote yourself with 100% of every ounce of energy you have to the perfection of all that you are involved with, or you exit dishonorably. So the question is not whether or not you are going to physically die. You are. The question is how did you live? How did you live?

Notice here that he is building a sense of urgency; subtly raising the fear and threat level. He also seems to be getting in a dig at people who slept the night before. (???) Sleep deprivation is a hallmark of cult programming. Sleep deprived people are more suggestible. And, as we know, later on there was food and water deprivation; something else that will make people suggestible. I also find it interesting that in addition to fluids being made available in time for the sweat lodge, there has also been much mention of watermelon. Watermelon is full of electrolytes and great for hydration. It's also full of something else: sugar. Going from near starvation to sugar shock is another classic cult snapping device.

Just listen. I'm not asking for your agreement or disagreement right now. I'm just giving examples of what we do in our life. We say that things are good or bad, right or wrong, black or white. But the fact is, that's not the actual truth. And what I'm going to get you to, if you allow me to take you there. I can't do it for you, but I can show you the door, is I am literally going to facilitate your expansion and enlightenment this week. And I told the dream team yesterday when we met, I said this is the most the noble thing you could ever do because where else on the planet could you say that you spent five days accelerating people's enlightenment. [emphasis added] Really. Because the more, again, you source from actuality and you live into reality, sourcing from actuality, and then you act instead of react. You work from vision versus sight. The universe is at your disposal and you are unlimited. You're absolutely unlimited. And one of the main reasons you're not creating the results you want financially right now, relationally, mentally, physically, spiritually is this very thing. You have decreased your magnetism because you don't want to embrace the darkness within you.

Okay... actuality, reality, blah, blah, blah... But the statement that really jumped out at me was the one I've bolded above. Where else on the planet?! Seriously? A James Arthur Ray seminar is the only place in all the world where people can become enlightened?

We also practice altered states which are the only things that have been empirically demonstrated to evolve you onward and upward. Altered states.

Huh? How has "onward and upward" ever been empirically demonstrated. It's completely subjective and I would venture to say that there has never been a double blind study on what "evolves" people "onward and upward." Secondly, there has been very little research on altered states and most of it is in the margins of science. Which is not to say I doubt the validity. Rick Strassman's research on DMT comes to mind. But I think we can safely say that his criteria was not what evolved people onward and upward.

But I don't think Ray was experimenting with hallucinogens that week. I'm sure we would have heard by now if any 'shrooms or ayahuasca had been recovered along with his stash of steroids. The altered states I believe he was promising here had to do with holotropic breath work developed by Stan Grof. The Holotropic Mind was required material for the seminar. The problem is that according to Stan Grof, Ray is not certified in holotropic breath work.

For instance, did you know that Dr. Grof started a certification program for Facilitators through Grof Transpersonal Training? The purpose of this is to promote professional and ethical practices governing Holotropic Breath work. When Dr. Groff and his wife retired, the management of the company was taken up by Cary Sparks and her husband Tav. Interestingly enough, I spoke with Cary and she says James Ray is absolutely not certified in use of their techniques. This again raises questions about his training, education, and legitimacy to be practicing and combining these techniques.

While some of Dr. Grof’s early work could be considered controversial due to the use of LSD, he has complied with legal guidelines and discontinued study when the substance was outlawed. I asked Dr. Grof if he had ever had any charges of unethical use brought against him and he stated he had not. In fact, he had never even heard of James Ray before this disastrous retreat. Its funny how many experts in the various fields that James Ray has bastardized have never even heard of him.

The prosecutor also played audio recordings of the "Samurai Game." This was the game in which Ray played God, with the power over life and death. During this game, and throughout the vision quest that followed, no one was allowed to speak. Here is a description from ABC news.

On the fourth day of the event, the group played a game inspired by the Tom Cruise film, "The Last Samurai,'' in which Ray played the part of "God." He was dressed in a white robe. No one was permitted to speak with him. His staff played Angels of Death, in black lipstick and grim reaper costumes.

But in the courtroom, jurors got to hear Ray explain in his own words:

Once again, no one can talk to God for any reason, except a priest. And I... Am... God! (long pause) If you talk to God for any reason, you die.

. . .

If death comes upon you, there is only one noble way to die and that is you fall immediately to the floor wherever you are. And, of course, because you're dead, you cannot move a muscle... ever. You cannot open your eyes because you're dead. You cannot scratch your nose or shift your body in any way because you're dead.

Polk clarified that those who were "dead" were not only immobilized. They were not able to use the bathroom facilities or join the living for dinner.

After the game of life and death, the still silent participants moved directly into the next segment: the vision quest.

You'll be taken out in pitch darkness. You may have no flashlight. You may have no watch. You may have no cellphone or electronics of any kind. You can have no water, no food, or snacks. The only thing you might bring which is really not traditional but I'm taking it easy on you. [emphasis added] You can bring your sleeping bag, clothes that you have on your back, your journal and something to write with.

Notice that Ray, here, also conveys himself as a bestower of mercy and reprieve, when he's not actively trying to break people down with physically and emotionally humiliating experiences. I still can't think of a reason other than humiliation for the homelessness exercise that Colleen Conaway was participating in when she apparently committed suicide. It's hard to miss the parallels between that and the vision quest that followed Ray's imitation of a capricious God.

Polk explains that during the vision quest, participants were directed to draw a small circle for themselves in which they were to stay for 36 hours. This means, among other things, that even if they had to eliminate, it had to be in that small circle. One participant asked Ray if it would be better to play "full on" and not sleep and Ray said, yes:

Because, again, many great opportunities and experiences can be stole by sleep.

So here we have a perfect storm of food, water, and sleep deprivation. Of course for those who "died" in the Samurai game -- like Kirby Brown -- the period without food, water, or bathroom facilities was substantially longer than those 36 hours.

Again, In Session still has not played all of the opening arguments. I have seen some other of the excerpted statements by Ray in other coverage, and some of it is truly shocking. Here's a round-up:

Prescott Daily Courier:

"I've been in a lot of lodges before," Ray said on the tape, which Polk played for the 18-member jury, "but there's no lodge like my lodge.

"You will feel like you're going to die. I guarantee it."

AZ Family:

“You must surrender to survive,” Ray reportedly said.

AZ Central:

The sweat lodge was not the "weenie-ass lodge like everyone else," Ray told the group in those audiotapes.

Ray talked a lot about death, using it as a metaphor for personal growth.

Repeatedly, he said, "It's not a question of whether you're going to die. You are. The question is: How did you live?"

On Oct. 8, 2009, as he prepped the lodge participants - there were 49 clients and eight volunteer aides - he said, "You have to get to a point where you surrender, and it's OK to die."

It's not just that all the references to death, however metaphorical, sound ghoulish in retrospect. It's that he repeatedly tells people that although they will feel like they are dying, they aren't. Think about that for a minute. A leader in whom they'd placed their trust was telling them not to listen to their own bodies because their own senses would be lying to them -- that he knew better than their own survival instincts what was actually happening to them.

Opening argments for the defense were made by Luis Li. He attacked what he called "the State's adults can't choose theory," and argued that participants signed waivers and were there of their own free will. He made the point that some people did leave the sweat lodge and that some -- even a burn victim -- went back in. These things seem contradictory to me. Why did they go back in when they were ill and injured if not because they thought what was expected of them was that they "play full on?" According to the prosecutor, the burn victim was invited back in by Ray.

Another thing Li made clear, that I don't think helps the defense, is that there was a volunteer who was a nurse. He also admitted that she was not specifically put in place for that reason. She just happened to be a nurse. He also claimed that some volunteers were trained in CPR, but it's unclear at this time exactly how they were staged and used when things went to hell. Beverley Bunn, a participant, claims that Ray would not let her perform CPR on her dying friend Kirby Brown. And volunteers, like participants, would be free to leave at any time. They're volunteers, not employees. Why weren't people with health credentials hired if this was going to be so physically rigorous? And this argument could backfire for another reason. Why would Ray be so willing to depend on volunteers for such an important function? For the same reason that he expected people to continue with the sweat lodge. Because of their fealty to him.

Li compared the event to a marathon, saying that Ray "knew it was gonna be tough, like a marathon." Now that's a piece of information that could really backfire. Marathoners train for weeks, generally twelve, before a marathon. This was a five day event from which people left their ordinary lives in office jobs and the like. Some of them, including Kirby Brown, were quite active and fit but even the very fit train extensively for a marathon. And the night before a marathon, no athlete goes 36 (or more) hours without sleep, water, or food. Quite the contrary.

The defense also argued that it was not the heat that killed Kirby Brown, James Shore, and Liz Neuman, but that there may have been toxins in the wood or blankets, which were apparently stored in the same shed as rat poison. So they are disputing the official findings of heatstroke and hyperthermia.

I hope there will be fuller coverage on In Session in the coming months. It's shaping up to be a very interesting trial.

All information on the trial comes from news articles with provided links or live courtroom footage on TruTV's "In Session" or CNN's live feed. All quotes and paraphrased statements that are not linked to a source document are my best attempt to transcribe material from live broadcasts.


Comments on this entry are closed, on this blog. If you wish to comment, please find this and all newer blog entries crossposted on Celestial Reflections.

Mar 1, 2011

James Arthur Ray Sweat Lodge Trial: Day 1



According the New York Times, opening arguments did go forward today in the James Arthur Ray trial. But whatever happened in that regard did so after In Session's trial coverage wrapped for the day. Instead, I watched a lot of the pregame show but an as yet unspecified problem with the jury delayed pretrial hearings and the beginning of the public trial. Here is a brief encapsulation from the Times.

A prosecutor, Sheila Polk, argued that Mr. Ray’s negligence caused the deaths of Kirby Brown, James Shore and Liz Neuman in October 2009. She said Mr. Ray conditioned the victims to put aside their inhibitions and trust him as a way of reaching enlightenment.

Luis Li, Mr. Ray’s lawyer, called the deaths accidental and said the victims had voluntarily entered the sweat lodge.

Mr. Li said that the victims were adults and had made their own decisions and that Mr. Ray held no power over them.

So, maybe they'll play recorded footage of these remarks tomorrow. I'd like to hear them. Today it was all commentary and an attempt to put the trial in context. Much of it was completely nauseating. I indulged in a little running commentary here. But there was very little in terms of in depth analysis; at best a little food for thought. Sunny Hostin comes off as a breathless star-fucker. She just sounds incredulous that someone associated with that "incredible" book The Secret and as famous as Ray could be facing these charges.

Beth Karas, in discussing the sweat lodge structure, claims the construction was overseen by a Native American named David Singing Bear. This is to explain that though it looks makeshift, it was actually a traditional structure. Throughout this discussion, she never refers to any tribal history but uses the generic term Native American repeatedly. Well, I had never heard of David Singing Bear so I used the google. There are some questions regarding his authenticity. I don't want to jump to any conclusions but there is not a lot of information to be found... Really, that's the problem. There is very little information on his background... on his own website.

In looking at his bio, it all seems a little vague. He lists a number of degrees, without naming a single school. He claims a Doctorate of Divinity but doesn't list the school. He also claims to be a Doctor of Metaphysics but I can't even think of an accredited institution that would offer such a thing. He says he's a Licensed Minister but doesn't say in what faith or by whom he was ordained. He claims to be a Licensed Mental Therapist. What does that even mean? I've never known of any mental health professional of any kind who called themselves a Mental Therapist. He claims to be a Vietnam Vet but never says what branch of the military or what unit. Anyone -- at least of a certain age -- can claim to be a Vietnam Vet. It's hard to prove otherwise, especially without a birth name.

If we look here, at least part of the mystery is solved. His ordination and at least some of his degrees come from the Universal Life Church, where I could fill up a shopping cart right now with a range of doctorates. For $29.00 I can be a Doctor of the Universe. No really.

So, Singing Bear's credentials seem a little dodgy. But you know what else I notice? If we look here at his services listing, there's something else missing in terms of credentials and it seems particularly germane to this case. Nowhere does it say anything about him offering or having any experience with sweat lodges. Just being generically Native American is not enough. Being of some Native American lineage does not automatically confer on a person the necessary knowledge and wisdom to know how to assemble and run a sweat lodge.

There was also a lot, and I mean a lot, of footage of James Arthur Ray doin' his thing. Another thing that struck me while I was being tortured with footage of Ray's various lectures is that he just seems so angry. It was really apparent to me when they ran this snippet of him talking about merging and falling in love with your work. There's something very jarring about listening to someone talk about love and divine union but whose voice and body language evoke nothing so much as Charlie Sheen in a public meltdown. (It gets really weird around the 8 minute mark.)




I've added Tragedy in Sedona to the bookstore. I found the interview with former Ray student Connie Joy very compelling. More information on her extreme learning experience can be found here. The Joys, whose long history with Ray includes the 2007 sweat lodge, make some very damning claims that will apparently not make it before a jury due to Darrow's exclusion of Ray's prior bad acts.

Ray, she said, was a charismatic man who seemed genuinely interested in the people around him, but he developed a Messiah complex.

. . .

She and her husband endured a sweat lodge ceremony in 2007. No one died then, but many became ill, including Connie.

"The sweat lodge was ridiculously hot for way too long," she said.

Richard Joy added, "All it was was an endurance test. We had no altered conscious state; it was an endurance test and it was a miserable time."

He explained why he was able to stay inside the tent for several hours, "I was able to tolerate a little more. I made sure I was on the edge of the tent and close to the ground, using my head to survive."

All information on the trial comes from news articles with provided links or live courtroom footage on TruTV's "In Session" or CNN's live feed. All quotes and paraphrased statements that are not linked to a source document are my best attempt to transcribe material from live broadcasts.


Comments on this entry are closed, on this blog. If you wish to comment, please find this and all newer blog entries crossposted on Celestial Reflections.

High Weirdness in Peru



A massive and thus far unexplained crack in the ground has opened up in Puno, Peru. Seismologists have confirmed that it is not the result of an earthquake but the cause has yet to be determined. A house was destroyed by the earth movement and, tragically, a five year old boy remains missing.

‘The exact cause of the crack in the earth still unknown. Peru’s geophysical institute ruled out the occurrence of an earthquake in the region, but what is clear is that the ground opened up and large blocks of earth can be observed scattered throughout the area.’
Over at the USGS website, the confirmation of the absence of earthquake activity in Peru on February 23, the date the mysterious crack appeared in southern Peru.

Apparently something similar happened in Bolivia last year but that can be at least partially explained by underground fires. The fires though, have not been fully explained. It's not one of those mine fires like in Centralia, PA. Those are well explained by human folly.

In yesterday's post on the Time Monks tipping point fulfillment language, one thing I didn't delve into was the earth change activity. Particularly in the Alien Addictions video, he discusses how the solar maximum cycle we're just entering will increase earthquake and other terra phenomena (and possibly cause a pole reversal). Earthquakes are already way up and according to High will get a whole lot worse. There has been, for instance, the weirdness of the earthquake swarm that is ongoing in Arkansas. The 4.7 on Sunday may be the most intense in 35 years but it's not as weird as the fact that they've been experiencing quake after quake for months now. These may or may or not be due to natural causes but where it gets dicey is the possibility of the New Madrid fault going. According to High, the US Government has been quietly allocating funds and resources to prepare for a major quake along the New Madrid. There is also reference, as per High, to a major California quake in an obscure US document. And, yes, I'm still very, very concerned about California.

But High also discusses some of the other existing and potential earth changes including another increasing phenomenon: sinkholes. According to High, sinkholes are increasing and not all of them can be tied to over-mining. They seem to be occurring naturally. If sinkholes and, now, giant cracks are just opening up on the planet surface, all bets are off.


Comments on this entry are closed, on this blog. If you wish to comment, please find this and all newer blog entries crossposted on Celestial Reflections.

The James Arthur Ray Trial Begins



Opening arguments will be presented today, as James Arthur Ray is finally tried for the deaths of three people in a sweat lodge ceremony gone horribly wrong.

He told them it was a good day to die so they could be born again.

"You're not going to die," self-help author and speaker James Arthur Ray told participants in the sweat lodge that day, they later recalled. "You may think you are, but you're not going to die ... You need to surrender to death to survive it."

The sweat lodge ceremony, the culmination of a five-day retreat in Sedona, Arizona, was meant to be a "rebirthing." But by the end of that day, October 8, 2009, two people had died. A third died nine days later, and -- authorities allege -- at least 15 others fell ill.

Ray, 53, is charged with three counts of reckless manslaughter in the deaths and could face up to 10 years in prison on each if convicted. Opening statements are set to begin in his trial Tuesday.

And it looks like the trial will be televised. TruTV (formerly Court TV) was granted permission to film the proceedings. You know what that means: I'll be front and center... with popcorn!!

Yavapai County Superior Court Judge Warren Darrow granted the request by In Session, formerly known as CourtV, to televise James Arthur Ray's trial. Ray has pleaded not guilty to the three manslaughter charges stemming from the deaths near Sedona in October 2009.

Darrow has allowed one still and one video camera in previous hearings, but had not addressed live coverage before Friday.

In Session's request said the live coverage would advance Arizona's tradition of courtroom access. Prohibiting it would be akin to telling the media when it can publish information, attorney David Bodney said.




Comments on this entry are closed, on this blog. If you wish to comment, please find this and all newer blog entries crossposted on Celestial Reflections.

Feb 28, 2011

Black Swans Overtake the Middle East



Last night Natalie Portman took home the Oscar for her performance in The Black Swan. The excitement around this film has been building since it hit the screens to great critical acclaim and then won the Golden Globe and Independent Spirit Awards for Portman. I haven't seen The Black Swan yet but the buzz has been hard to escape. As with any phenomenon that captures headlines and imaginations, recognizable archetypes emerge. Even in the worst of pop culture, there are insights into the collective psyche and shared vision.

Several years before the Portman vehicle began making the news, a bestselling book by the same name created a different sort of buzz. Nassim Nicholas Taleb makes the convincing argument that events that create the greatest impact are unexpected and unpredictable based on past patterns. He uses the black swan as a metaphor for these unexpected events. Before the discovery and colonization of Australia, the black swan was a metaphor for something non-existent and, therefore, inconceivable. It was common knowledge throughout Europe and its colonies that all swans were white. But in 1697 the great birds were discovered by Willem de Vlaming's expedition along Australia's Swan River. With the discovery, a fundamental assumption about the world collapsed and a colloquialism was turned on its head.

So the black swan emerges as an archetype for radical shifts that fly in the face of our assumptions about our reality and have the greatest potential to create change in the world. And, it is against the backdrop of a rapidly changing world that Natalie Portman has been picking up her awards and accolades. Which, of course, brings me back to the Time Monks tipping point prediction.